← All articles

Get new article notifications.

How to test drive a used car

Part 3 of a series. Part 1 is the inspection checklist, and Part 2 is how to negotiate at the lot.

A test drive is your chance to find problems with the car before you've purchased it. Once it's yours, you own that vehicle as-is and are responsible for any fixes that are needed.

Most people take a quick loop around the block with the radio on and call it a test drive. I like to be a lot more thorough than that and here's what I look for in a test drive.

Start it cold

When you pull up to the lot or the owner's home, check if the car is already running or warm. It's a red flag for me if it's running when i get there, because a warm engine often hides the things a cold engine won't such as rough idling, engine ticking, heavy smoke out the tail pipe on startup, a check-engine light that pops and then clears.

You can ask them not to start it until you get there if you want, but I usually do not ask them. My reasoning is that if it's running when i get there than I already know there's an issue with it and I will say I've changed my mind and walk away.

Plug in a scanner before you drive

A seller who warms the car up before you arrive may also have cleared the check engine light. The light goes out, but the car keeps the record, and a scanner reads it back. An OBD2 scanner plugs into a port under the dash on anything sold since 1996 and tells you two things the dashboard will not. The first is which codes were stored since the last reset. The second is whether the emissions monitors have finished running, because monitors still reading “not ready” mean the computer was cleared recently, and on a car being sold that morning that is worth asking about.

Drive it long enough to find something

Plan on 15 minutes minimum, and try to drive it on a few different types of road:

  • Stop-and-go through a neighborhood or parking lot, so the transmission has a chance to shift up and down and the brakes get used.
  • Highway speeds, 60+ mph, for at least 5 minutes. Alignment problems, wheel balance, bearing noise, and transmission issues at cruising RPM all show up at higher speeds.
  • A speed bump and a rough patch of road. If the car crashes over bumps, keeps bouncing after a speed bump or clunks on uneven pavement, the shocks or struts will likely need to be repaired.

Keep in mind that a used car is... well, a used car. It's going to have issues and will probably not be perfect. The mindset I take on test drives and car inspections is that I'm building up leverage for the price negotiation. If it's obvious the car will need new brakes and new rotors because it's pulsing when you hit the brakes, then that is worth mentioning when you start talking price. It might be compelling enough for the seller to take a couple hundred dollars off the price just because you mentioned it, to make sure you will still buy the car.

What to feel for

While you're driving, these are the specific things you're checking:

  • Brake pedal. It should feel firm. A pedal that sinks slowly toward the floor under steady pressure is a master cylinder or a leak in the system. A pedal that pulses when you brake from speed means warped rotors.
  • Steering wheel at highway speed. Any vibration at 60+ mph is a balance or alignment problem at best, a bent wheel or worn suspension part at worst.
  • Alignment. On a flat, straight, empty stretch of road, take your hands off the wheel for a few seconds. The car should track straight. A pull left or right means alignment, uneven tire wear, or something worse.
  • Transmission. It should shift cleanly. A transmission that hunts between gears on a slight grade, slips, or shifts hard is expensive to fix.
  • Accelerator. Press through the pedal from a stop and at cruising speed. A soft spot where the car hesitates before responding is often a sensor, sometimes a fuel delivery problem, and occasionally it's transmission.
  • CV joints. In an empty parking lot, turn the wheel to full lock and drive a slow tight circle both directions. A clicking or popping sound from the front wheels is likely a worn CV joint.
  • Hard braking. In that same empty lot, get up to 30 or so and brake hard. The car should stop straight without pulling to one side and without the pedal pulsing. If it pulls left or right during braking then the alignment will need to be fixed.

What to listen for

Drive with the radio off for the entire test (you can check the sound system in the parking lot after you've driven it). Then run through a couple of passes with the windows up and the windows down.

With the windows up, listen for wind noise around the door seals, because a leaking seal will let water in too. With the windows down, listen for a hum or whine from the wheels that rises and falls with speed, which is usually a wheel bearing on its way out.

Run the A/C on max for a few minutes and confirm the air gets genuinely cold, not just cool. Then switch to heat on max and confirm it gets hot. Don't run them at the same time. When the dealer says "it probably just needs a recharge" make a mental note that A/C repairs are expensive.

No car is perfect but this test drive plan should keep you from buying an obvious lemon. The hardest part is remaining objective when you love the car. It's hard to see issues when all you see is what your heart is telling you to see, which is usually only the positive aspects of the car.

Save on computers & electronics

Posts on this site contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Leave a comment

Comments are moderated — I read every one. Your email is only used if I need to follow up; it isn't published. Links aren't allowed.

← All articles