← All articles

Get new article notifications.

Part 3 of 3: The cloud side of backing up your family photos

Part 3 of a 3-part series. Part 1 covered the 3-2-1 rule and why most people's setups don't qualify as a backup, and Part 2 covered the local hard-drive half. This part covers the offsite copy, which is the cloud service slot in the setup.

The offsite copy is the one that saves you when the house burns down, when a thief takes the laptop and the external drive sitting next to it, or when a pipe breaks above the closet where you keep your backup drive.

For most people, that means the cloud. The question is which cloud, and what role it's playing — because the four services people reach for first are not the same product, even though they all show your photos in a grid.

iCloud Photos

iCloud is what many iPhone owners are already using, often without realizing it counts as anything. It's a sync service first and a backup service second, and that distinction matters. If you delete a photo on your phone, it deletes from iCloud too, and you have 30 days in the Recently Deleted folder before it's gone for good. As the offsite copy in a 3-2-1 setup, it works, but only because you also have the originals on a hard drive at home — if iCloud is your only copy, you don't have a backup; you have a single copy that happens to live on someone else's computer.

Your photos appear on every Apple device you own, and the storage is cheap. If you stop paying, Apple keeps your photos for a grace period and then starts deleting them. The deletion schedule is real and not negotiable, and they do give you plenty of warning before it starts.

Google Photos

Google Photos is the strongest of the four at finding things. Search for "birthday cake 2019" or "grandma at the beach" and it finds them. The free tier no longer covers new uploads at original quality, so you're paying for Google One storage if you have any meaningful library.

The same sync-not-backup warning applies: delete on the phone and it deletes in the cloud, with a 60-day trash window. If you stop paying for Google One and you're over the free limit, Google will eventually delete content to bring you back under quota.

Amazon Photos

Amazon Photos is the sleeper here. If you're already paying for Amazon Prime, you get unlimited full-resolution photo storage included, with no compression and no downscaling. Video storage is limited and counts against your regular Amazon Drive quota, but for photos alone it's the best deal in the category. The app has search and organization that are noticeably weaker than Google's, but for the specific job of holding a copy of every photo at full resolution, offsite, for no additional money, it's hard to beat. If you cancel Prime, you have 180 days before they start deleting, which is more runway than the others give you.

IDrive

IDrive is the only one of these four that's a backup service rather than a photo service. You install it on your computer, point it at your drives — including your external photo drive — and it backs up every file on them continuously, for about $70 the first year and around $100 a year after that. The Personal plan is 5TB, and that one allowance covers every device you own instead of charging you per computer.

The key difference is what happens when you delete a file on your computer: IDrive keeps up to 30 previous versions of every file, and those versions don't count against your 5TB. It's not trying to mirror your library in real time; it's trying to save you from an accidental delete or a ransomware attack. Pair IDrive with the external drive from Part 2, and your photos are protected against drive failure, accidental deletion, ransomware, and the house burning down.

Which service covers the offsite copy

The phone and the computer are one copy. The external hard drive from Part 2 is the second copy on a second kind of media. The cloud service you pick is the third copy, living somewhere your house can't reach. A single drive failure, a stolen laptop, a house fire, or an accidental delete won't take your family's photos with it because all three copies would have to go at once.

If you have read all three parts and done nothing yet, the smallest useful step is the third copy, because it's the one that survives everything the first two don't. Set up the cloud half this week and the drive can wait for payday. Starting an IDrive account takes about ten minutes, and the first backup runs by itself overnight while you sleep.

Save on computers & electronics

Posts on this site contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.

Leave a comment

Comments are moderated — I read every one. Your email is only used if I need to follow up; it isn't published. Links aren't allowed.

← All articles